Shinas Estate "The Guilty" Shiraz 2005
Sometimes you can get lost in a wine. Or just lost - period. There's nothing wrong with letting go at these times. Not every mystery has to be solved. Let's face it, some wines, like some days, pose more questions than they answer, and it could be that we're better for it.
I kept having a sense of "deja vu" coming over me with this wine. "What's that smell, familiar yet elusive?" Or as Morrissey once put it, "Stop me, oh-oh-oh stop me; Stop me if you think that you've heard this one before." But for me the words never came, not even in the course of opening and tasting from 2 bottles.
George Shinas, aka "The Judge", himself actually a criminal judge in Mildura, Victoria, Australia, has created a Shiraz that's rather like staring out into the sea at 1 a.m. You're drawn to its power and mystery, and captivated by its depth and infinity. You may want to describe it but the words you need remain on the tip of your tongue. It keeps you up a while before you finally let go. Tomorrow's another day and chances are, the next wine will show its face in the light of day, and the words will come to you to describe it.
Shinas Estate Shiraz 2005 has an unfiltered appearance, deep dark crimson. You might sense sweet spice, roasted dark chocolate and earthy notes over the top of the loganberry and blackberry fruit aromas. The finish lingers, like the best words to describe the whole experience, on the tip of your tongue, until you give up.
Judge Shinas reportedly only makes about 2000 cases of this Shiraz annually, so there isn't enough to go around. If you see it, you might want to grab a few bottles. Vine Street Imports represents in the USA.
Price: $19 (Nashville). Closure: Screw cap. Alcohol content: 15.3%.











Recent Comments